Cileccta Review

Life-cycle costing

Compare cost and carbon without merging their units

Cileccta Review · Published 4 November 2026 · Original editorial guide

Set up parallel cost and carbon records with a shared service description, explicit boundaries and separately reported results.

Start with the same service description

Write what each building option delivers before comparing either cost or environmental results. Use the same capacity, floor-area definition where relevant, operating pattern and study period. If one assessment uses a different scope, identify that difference before placing the results next to each other.

Keep two registers

A payment belongs in the cost register with currency, price date and payment timing. An environmental result belongs in its own record with indicator, unit, product or process boundary, data source and assessment period. A supplier's price is not an emissions factor. A product declaration is not a maintenance quotation.

Write the included stages beside the result

A construction-stage figure and a result covering operation and later replacements answer different questions. State the included stages in plain language and retain their formal labels where the underlying method uses them. Identify transport, site work, energy use, replacement and end-of-life treatment as included, excluded or unestimated.

Use a comparison sheet with separate outputs

For each option, show the cost total and its calculation basis in one column, and the environmental result and its declared basis in another. Keep a third column for missing evidence. Do not combine euros and kilograms into an unexplained score. If a project uses weighting or a carbon price, document that separate decision rule and its authority.

Explain a trade-off without inventing a winner

In an original fictional illustration, Option A costs €20,000 and has a stated assessment result of 8 tonnes CO₂e; Option B costs €23,000 and has 6 tonnes CO₂e under the same assumed scope. The table shows a €3,000 cost difference and a 2-tonne difference. It does not choose the preferred option without the client's decision criteria. These invented values describe no product or building.

Check the evidence behind both columns

Ask who produced each assessment, which version was used, and whether it covers the selected specification. Keep uncertainty and data gaps attached to their own results. Do not describe a cheaper option as lower carbon without the separate evidence. Publish a conclusion only within the stated boundaries.