Cileccta Review

Life-cycle costing

Keep discounted comparisons and cash budgets side by side

Cileccta Review · Published 4 November 2026 · Original editorial guide

A five-year fictional cash schedule shows why present-value comparison and payment-year budgeting need separate views of the same inputs.

Use one event list and two views

The cash budget answers when money must be available. A discounted comparison expresses dated amounts at a common date. Keep both views connected to the same event list. When a quotation changes, update the source row and regenerate both views so they do not drift apart.

State the convention before the formula

Our fictional example places the initial payment at time zero and every later payment at the end of the year. Amounts use constant base-date prices, with no separate price escalation. The illustrative real discount rate is 3% a year. It is an invented teaching assumption, not a recommended rate for a real project.

Calculate a single payment first

For an amount C paid at the end of year t, this example uses present value C / (1 + r)^t. With r = 0.03, a €2,000 payment at the end of year 3 has a present value of €1,830.28. Retain unrounded values in the working calculation and round only the displayed figures.

Original fictional schedule — payments at each year end
YearCash paymentReason
0€10,000Initial works
1€1,200Operation
2€1,200Operation
3€3,200Operation plus €2,000 event
4€1,200Operation
5€1,200Operation

Keep the year-three payment visible

The table assumes €10,000 initially, annual operating payments of €1,200 for five years, and an additional €2,000 event in year 3. The undiscounted total is €18,000. The present-value total is €17,325.93. Year 3 still needs €3,200 of cash under these base-price assumptions; the discounted figure does not replace that budget requirement.

Keep price and rate conventions consistent

Label the treatment of inflation next to the rate. Do not mix constant-price cash flows with a nominal rate without making the required adjustment. Retain any service-specific escalation separately from general inflation. Ask the model reviewer to check the convention as well as the arithmetic.

Use the result for its stated purpose

A lower present-value total does not establish that a payment is affordable in its due year. Give the decision team both the comparison and the annual cash schedule. Record the rate's authority and the timing convention for an actual assessment; change the illustrative assumptions before using this example for a project.