Cileccta Review

Replacement decisions

Repair or replace: compare the next decision on equal terms

Cileccta Review · Published 4 November 2026 · Original editorial guide

An original fictional example compares immediate repair, immediate replacement and a staged plan over the same twelve-year service period.

Check feasibility before cost

Ask whether each option delivers the required service and meets the project's safety and performance requirements. A cost table does not establish that an ageing asset is fit to remain in use. Exclude an infeasible repair or add the work needed to make it feasible before comparing totals.

Define the next twelve years

The example below is fictional. All three plans provide an assumed identical service for twelve years. Amounts are invented euros at one price date, with no inflation or discounting. Annual operating amounts include the routine maintenance assumed for each plan. There is no residual credit or end-of-period charge. These assumptions support an arithmetic demonstration, not a purchasing recommendation.

Read the three event schedules

Repair now costs €4,000, followed by €1,400 each year and an €8,000 replacement at the end of year 5. Replace now costs €12,000, followed by €650 each year. The staged plan costs €2,500 now, €1,800 annually in years 1–3, €10,000 for replacement at the end of year 3, then €700 annually in years 4–12. The annual assumptions are held fixed within each stated period.

Fictional example — undiscounted twelve-year cash totals
PlanCalculationTotal
Repair now4,000 + 12 × 1,400 + 8,000€28,800
Replace now12,000 + 12 × 650€19,800
Stage the replacement2,500 + 3 × 1,800 + 10,000 + 9 × 700€24,200

Inspect the cash requirements

In this example, immediate replacement has the lowest undiscounted total. The staged plan requires €11,800 in year 3: its €1,800 annual cost plus the €10,000 replacement. A single annual average would conceal that payment. Retain the year-by-year schedule before discussing affordability.

Test the assumptions that choose the winner

For an actual project, obtain evidence for the initial scope, annual demand, repair coverage and later replacement cost. Apply a consistent discounting convention if the decision requires a present-value comparison. Recalculate each plan on the same basis. Do not carry the ranking from this fictional cash-total table into a different model.

Write the decision record

Record the selected plan, assumptions that determine the ranking, remaining evidence gaps and responsibility for the next inspection. Attach the event schedule. If procurement changes the specification or maintenance coverage, update the comparison before treating the decision as settled.