Cileccta Review

Replacement decisions

Show what remains at the end of the study period

Cileccta Review · Published 4 November 2026 · Original editorial guide

Make remaining service potential and end-of-period costs explicit without treating an accounting allowance as a guaranteed resale receipt.

Draw the study end through the schedule

A replacement near the end of a comparison period creates a boundary question: the asset continues beyond the last modelled year. Record the replacement event, study end and assumed service period together. Use the same end-of-period convention for comparable options and explain its effect on the result.

Distinguish a credit from a cash receipt

An allowance for remaining service potential is a modelling choice. It is not evidence that somebody will buy the asset for that amount. If the model includes an actual sale, support the receipt and associated costs separately. Do not enter a remaining-service allowance and a sale receipt for the same benefit.

Inspect an original simplified example

This fictional example uses a €6,000 component installed at the start of year 8. The study ends at the start of year 12, so four years have elapsed. Assume a ten-year service period and a deliberately simplified straight-line allocation. Six years remain, giving an illustrative allowance of €6,000 × 6 / 10 = €3,600 at the study end. This is not a market valuation or a mandated residual-value method.

Show the comparison without the allowance

Keep the base calculation and add a second view with the €3,600 allowance removed. If the ranking changes, show that dependency explicitly and obtain stronger evidence for the chosen treatment. Where the study uses discounting, put the allowance at the correct study-end date and apply the same convention as other dated amounts.

Include the work that ends the service

Removal, transport, making good and disposal need their own scope and payment timing when they fall within the comparison boundary. Record which items are included in quotations. A positive residual assumption does not erase an outstanding removal obligation. Keep the two entries traceable.

Record the method and its limit

Finish the note with the reason for the chosen convention, its source, the assumed remaining service and the scenario that tests it. For an actual assessment, follow the method required by the commissioning brief and obtain the relevant professional review. Do not label this editorial example as a formal appraisal.